Showing posts with label S.K. Maitra. Show all posts
Showing posts with label S.K. Maitra. Show all posts

February 02, 2013

Meeting of the East and the West in Sri Aurobindo, Bergson, Heidegger, and Deleuze

THERE IS NO SHORTCUT TO HAPPINESS times of india - speaking tree By: Ramesh Bijlani on Feb 01, 2013
What it means is that happiness resides not in the car, but in ‘not wanting anything’. ‘Not wanting anything’ is an inner state to be cultivated, not a goal automatically reached by fulfillment of desires. The conclusion is that happiness is within us, not in the object outside. Let us take another example. A person goes and donates a unit of blood. That makes him happy. He has not got anything – in fact, he has given something. The person is happy because while donating blood he thought of another individual in need. In the process, he got so completely absorbed in somebody else’s need that he forgot what he himself wants. In other words, he was once again in a state of ‘not wanting anything’. Thus, to be happy, we need not get anything at all. In fact, the joy of giving is much greater than the joy of getting.
The above discussion exposes the two major flaws in the popular notion that happiness comes from getting things. One, happiness resides not in the things outside but within us; and two, true happiness comes from giving. But what we generally do is to look outside for happiness – in the objects that we want, in the work that we do, in the people to whom we are attached, in being healthy, and so on. All these are entities which are inconstant, unreliable, erratic and unpredictable. The objects that seem to give us happiness are perishable, the happiness they give is short-lasting, and the list of still more objects that we may want is endless. In case of a few fortunate ones, the work that they enjoy doing coincides with the work that they have to do for a living. Even these fortunate ones cannot go on doing the same work for ever: enforced ‘superannuation’ or bodily disability might force them to give up the work. People to whom we are attached do not always behave the way we would like them to. 

Understanding Medical Physiology - Page 876 - Bijlani - 2004 - Preview - More editions The basic text of integral yoga is The Synthesis of Yoga by Sri Aurobindo. CONCLUSION Yoga is an ancient system of Indian philosophy. Although its metaphysical aspects are complex, the fundamentals, as applicable to daily life, are quite ...

The meeting of the East and the West in Sri Aurobindo's philosophy - Page 165 - S.K. Maitra - 1956 - This statement we can look upon as containing the essence of Sri Aurobindo's conception of yoga, as, in fact, the text of integral yoga. The first thing which it asserts is that yoga is a birth. It is not a dissolution, nor an absorption, nor a swooning away into the Divine, but it is a birth. That is to say, the human being retains his character as a human being, which means as a being with a body, life, soul and mind, and having a part to ...

Leather, Fur, & Legendary Joy: A Response from Joshua Ramey to Beatrice Marovich’s “‘We Dance These Beasts’: Capitalism, Animism, Believers of the Future” from An und für sich by Joshua Ramey
As anyone who knows me knows, I spend as much of my time as I can drumming or dancing (when I’m not reading and writing and teaching).  Part of why I was drawn to Deleuze in the first place was that he seemed to be one of the few philosophers willing to lend some language to what was crucial for me about movement and rhythm, conceptually as well as at the affective level, and willing to take the emendation of the affects as far as the emendation of the intellect toward the composition of a philosophical life.  Deleuze was always, in a typically French way, reticent about being anecdotal, and I think he knew how to be revealing enough without anecdotes.  I’m not quite that refined.  Beatrice has moved me to relay, anecdotally, an experience that, for me, forms a kind of legend for the defense of spirituality Beatrice is drawing attention to between the lines of my book…
At any rate, I have often thought to myself that from the 1960’s to 2013 the spiritual stakes of experimentation have changed:  what was an aesthetic choice, then, has become a survival strategy, now.  For those of us with anything left to experiment with, survival itself has become experimental.  In the context of endless and irremediable debts, of a totally debt-leveraged existence, everything is improvisation, everything is experimentation.  Existence itself is spiritual ordeal, for those who manage to survive the imperative to “invest in oneself” at the cost of everything, and at the cost of everything manage to pretend to be an “entrepreneur of the self,” while in fact this means to take on the weight of the world, the burden of the global, ever-imploding debt.

I would argue, however—with Laruelle’s theory of the fundamental autonomy of heresy and gnosis—that the reverse is the case, that it is orthodoxy that is more or less parasitic, in the long run, on religious experiences that are too wild, too intense, too idiosyncratic to regulate, order, and habituate.  (It’s true that Bergson’s view of religion is similar, but I don’t hold to Bergson’s ontology of development, which overemphasizes continuity). From that perspective, let me engage in some heretical theology.  The logic of exemplarity in standard Christian philosophy is a logic that attempts to provide limits or conditions for possible spiritual experimentation, in advance of ordeal. 
But from my perspective, and the perspective that I call “the hermetic Deleuze,” since every ordeal potentially is unlimited, any ordeal can exemplify any other, to the degree that it resonates with any other ordeal. This is where Bruno did not so much reject incarnationalism as rather accelerate it into a kind of terracarnationalism or cosmicarnationalism, a becoming-divine or being-divine of everything in relation to everything else.  This has obvious overtones of mystical theophanies such as Eriugena’s, and in alchemical theologies like Boehme’s. The problem with the “standard Christian philosophy,” as Bruno saw it, and as Deleuze put it borrowing a phrase from D.H. Lawrence, is that it is not yet ready “to have done with judgment.” 

(title unknown) from enowning Tomonobu Imamichi says The Book of Tea was there first. 
[Ito Kichinosuke, one of my teachers at university, studied in Germany in 1918 immediately after the First World War and hired Heidegger as a private tutor. Before moving back to Japan at the end of his studies, Professor Ito handed Heidegger a copy of Das Buch vom Tee, the German translation of Okakura Kkuzo's The Book of Tea, as a token of his appreciation. That was in 1919. Sein und Zeit was published in 1927, and made Heidegger famous. Mr. Ito was surprised and indignant that Heidegger used Zhuangzi's concept without giving him credit. Years later in 1945, Professor Ito reminisced with me and, speaking in his Shonai dialect, said, "Heidegger did a lot for me, but I should've laid into him for stealing." There are other indications that Heidegger was inspired by Eastern writings, but let's leave this topic here. I have heard many stories of this kind from Professor Ito and checked their veracity.] [The meaningfulness of the tea cup, in 1919. P. 83]

November 29, 2012

Those who grew up under The Mother’s personal care have betrayed her

The Trustees derive their power from the divine and secular centre that the Mother occupied when She was physically present. Disciples and followers unquestioningly accepted Her authority and had full faith in Her divine knowledge both in spiritual and worldly matters. That physical space having fallen vacant in November 1973, the first Trustees and heads of departments chosen by the Mother continued to hold sway over the community for a couple of decades by acting with sufficient maturity and tact. As they quietly exited the mortal scene and were replaced by those who were not directly chosen by the Mother, the moral credibility of the next batch of Trustees and heads of departments rapidly diminished and, within a decade or two, all that remained was their legal authority.
In this respect, devotees from outside, who have settled in the Ashram from a long time, and the so-called home grown “children of the Mother” are both responsible for this administrative deterioration. As a matter of fact, if anybody has betrayed Sri Aurobindo and the Mother in the present crisis, it is the generation that grew up under the Mother’s personal care – there are of course a few exceptions who unfortunately have not been able to assert themselves effectively. [Cf. A Basic Scheme for Sri Aurobindo Ashram – proposed by an Ashramite.]

IIM-A's decision comes on the back of the premier B-school being awarded a Rs one crore top grant from Education Innovation Fund for India (EIFI), a collaborative project between the HP Sustainability & Social Innovation group and the India Council for Integral Education (ICIE), an initiative of the Sri Aurobindo Society.

The Journal of the Bihar Research Society - Volume 42 - Page 224 - Bihar Research Society - 1956 - Mature of History The basic concepts of Aurobindo 's philosophy — Sachchidananda or the Supreme Spiritual reality, supermind and evolutionary progression are the foundations on which is constructed...

Towards a new India - Page 27 - Karan Singh (Sadr-i-Riyasat of Jammu and Kashmir) - 1974 - The two important concepts of Aurobindo, then, were of the nation as a spiritual entity and of nationalism as the highest sadhana. Besides Aurobindo felt that because India had been violently subjugated, she was fully justified, in using ...

The perennial quest for a psychology with a soul: an inquiry into ... - Page 542 - Joseph Vrinte - 2002 - Preview Ken Wilber's all-quadrant, all-level approach aims at a multi-causal analysis without reducing one to the other. Could it be that the weak areas that Ken Wilber identified are more closely related to Sri Aurobindo's disciples than to his vision?

Teilhard De Chardin and Eastern Religions: Spirituality and ... - Page 227 - Ursula KingJoseph Needham - 2011 - Preview - Yet it is of little help in furthering understanding or comparative assessment when some of Aurobindo's disciples maintain that Teilhard has written little that Aurobindo has not expressed much better or claim that the latter has in fact ...

The philosophy of Sri Aurobindo in the light of the Gospel - Page 71 Eva Olsson - 1959 - But such are as a rule not found among Sri Aurobindo's disciples, who consider the sense of guilt of sin as the cause of the inferiority complex in man, discouraging his own efforts to rise. According to Sri Aurobindo man's own efforts are a ...

The Lives of Sri Aurobindo - Page 369 - Peter Heehs - 2008 - Preview - Around 1930 some of Sri Aurobindo's disciples began to ask him questions about poetry and to send him poems for evaluation. He seems to have relished this correspondence, writing replies covering a half-dozen literatures and a dazzling ...

History of dharmaśāstra: (ancient and mediæval religious and civil ... - Page 1466 - ṇḍuraga Vāmana KāeBhandarkar Oriental Research Institute - Can anybody point out even half a dozen men and disciples of Aurobindo who have devoted all their energies to the regeneration of the country and of the human race on his lines ? The position of the Ashram itself is rather vague, anomalous ...

Asia: Asian quarterly of culture and synthesis - Volume 1 - Page 221 - René de Berval - 1951 - The disciples of Aurobindo have expressed in moving terms the remembrance of their Master. They have extolled the superhuman majesty of each his look, each movement, each way of his, despite the modest and gentle expression which he ...

The genius of India - Page 145 - Guy Sorman - 2001 - It is near Pondicherry that the disciples of Aurobindo have built a contemporary Tower of Babel. In February 1968, a few weeks before May 1968, thousands of young men and women, in response to a call from the Mother, congregated from all...

Vishnu on Freud's desk: a reader in psychoanalysis and Hinduism - Page 56 - T. G. VaidyanathanJeffrey John Kripal - 1999 - various disciples of Aurobindo and Ramakrishna and, of course, a notable correspondence with Mahatma Gandhi.34 'The Unity of Europe and Asia', he wrote, 'must be, in the coming centuries, the most noble task of mankind'.35 Starting in ...

Modern Vedanta - Page 235  - P. K. Das - 2004 - Scholars of Sri Aurobindo's thought, like late Prof. S.K. Maitra, consider Sri Aurobindo's speculation about the future of man as the most important aspect of his philosophy. This, however, is not the near future but a distant far off time, so far ...

The Eastern journal of international law: quarterly organ of the ... - Volume 10 - Page 43 - Eastern Centre of International Studies - 1978 - The view that the East is East and West is West stands to be refuted and hence scholars of Sri Aurobindo's philosophy seem to justify his theory of evolution as a true reconciliation between the East and the West. According to them, a meeting ... Indian philosophical annual - Volumes 8-11 - Page 139 - University of Madras. Centre of Advanced Study in Philosophy - 1976 

The Journal of Indian writing in English - Volume 33 - Page 85 - G. S. Balarama Gupta - 2005 - The ease with which the writer relates Sri Aurobindo's yogic career with the poetic career, and the profusion of critical support he draws upon, makes this book a convenient first book for other aspirant scholars of Sri Aurobindo, as well as an ...

Colorado's Sanctuaries, Retreats, and Sacred Places - Jean TorkelsonBill Bonebrake - 2001 - Preview As read by Aurobindo scholars and disciples, the poem is a mantra that followers use to achieve spiritual illumination. No mention of Aurobindo's life would be complete without paying tribute to his spiritual co-worker, known to disciples as The...

The Yoga Party: Philosophical Writings - Page 15 - Douglas E Frame - 2009 - Preview ... you have an evolution of the body, so also is there an evolution of the spirit and contrariwise. The most interesting thing I find in Sri Aurobindo and I'm sure Aurobindo scholars would concur, is that you don't need to escape rebirth to become ...

Sri Aurobindo and his contemporary thinkers - Page 136 - Indrani SanyalKrishna RoyJadavpur University - 2007 - As we know, it is through the commendable efforts of some living scholars like Dr Kireet Joshi of the ICPR, Sri Samar Basu of the World Union of Sri Aurobindo Ashram, Pondicherry and other Sri Aurobindo scholars of repute that Sri Aurobindo ...
Gandhi-Aurobindo and Radhakrishnan on Bhagavadgita - Page 123 - Susmit Prasad PaniGeeta Satpathy - 2009 - ... and the interpretations of eminent scholars like Bal Gangadhar Tilak and Sri Aurobindo. Scholars suspected that Gandhi had given a twist to the Gita to fit his doctrine of non-violence, and that his view was effected by the study of the Bible.

Indian and foreign review - Volume 10 - Page ccxx - India. Ministry of Information and Broadcasting. Publications Division – 1972 - Despite differences over basic issues, Tilak hailed Ranade as "a man of vision and action". Mahadeo Govind Ranade was a "man of God", ...

The Plays of Sri Aurobindo, a study - Page 1 - S. S. Kulkarni - 1990 - Various Aurobindo scholars have established him as an important Indian English poet. The bulk and the quality of his poems and plays published in the Birth Centenary Library series justify his claim that he was a poet first and everything else...

Sri Aurobindo's plays: a thematic study - Page xi - Sheo Jaiswal - 1993 - I owe special debt of gratitude to all other eminent Sri Aurobindo scholars, especially Prof. K.R.S. Iyengar, Mr. K.D. Sethna, Dr. Prema Nandkumar, Mr. M.V. Seetaraman, Dr. V.K. Gokak as also Prof. M.K. Naik and Dr. A.K. Sinha, whose works ...

Indian literature in English, 1827-1979: a guide to information ... - Page 476 - Amritjit SinghRajiva VermaIrene M. Joshi - 1981 - Chambersburg, Pa.: Wilson Books, 1974. Includes six essays by Aurobindo scholars from the West. Mehta, Rohit. THE BEING AND THE BECOMING; THOUGHTS ON SRI AUROBINDO'S ESSAYS ON THE GITA. Ahmedabad: R.N. Amin, 1975.

Journal of Indian psychology - Volume 22 - Page 75 - Andhra University - 2004 - ... more commendable scholarly service if he had chosen to develop Aurobindo's vision and thought to address the disturbing puzzles and limitations of contemporary psychological thought. lt is not unlikely that many Aurobindo scholars would ...

Triveni - Volume 52 - Page 30 1983 - This fundamental similarity between Cousins and Sri Aurobindo has not received sufficient attention from Aurobindo scholars and critics because of the fact that Cousins ' name disappeared from the literary horizon and Sri Aurobindo shot up ... Journal of South Asian literature - Volumes 24-25 - Page 120 - Michigan State University. Asian Studies Center - 1989

Tamil civilization: quarterly research journal of the Tamil University - Volume 6 - Page 71 - Tañcai Tamip Palkalaik Kaakam - 1988 - Seeing that this idea is a central element in the thought-structure of Sri Aurobindo, scholars have introduced this expression while discussing the teachings of Sri Aurobindo. However it does not mean that the term 'integralism' is of secondary ...