Even the smallest meanest work became A sweet or glad and glorious sacrament.
February 29, 2020
Idealism and panpsychism make easy friends
February 22, 2020
Socratic irony, Galileo's error, and Gargi's silence
— Śrīpād Bhakti Mādhava Purī Mahārāja, Ph.D.
Due to this overcoming of its own limit, The Idea becomes the idea outside of itself by expressing itself in Its Other, i.e. Nature. The Idea does not exist only in the Thought, but also in Thought’s opposite, i.e. extension. Therefore Nature includes all forms of self externality.
That’s why the concept of death becomes important. Hegel says Die to Live [4[. Because Reality (Spirit) is by and for itself. When we can die in externality, i.e. in the search for so called freedom, that we actually become free for the first time. That is the Spiritual World, where truth is spontaneous, or free. There is some appearance of freedom in Nature, no doubt, but that is not in the true sublated form. Just like a prisoner is doing something in the jail, but we know that the jail is not his real home. Therefore the Spiritual world is the true home soil. Therefore everyone becomes free for the first time when they come in harmony with Reality.
Bhakti Vijnana Muni
Srila Bhakti Rakshak Sridhar Deva Goswami Maharaja, the founder of Sri Chaitanya Saraswat Math recognized that among all western philosophers, Hegel was very good. And we also in turn heard some of these topics from our Gurudev, Sripad Bhakti Madhava Puri Maharaja Phd. And everyone can derive great benefit from his association and contributing to his service as he served many great personalities like Srila BR Sridhar Maharaja and Srila AC Bhakti Vedanta Swami Prabhupada.
The subjects of Socrates' conversations often revolved around search for a definition focused on the true nature of the subject under question and not just on how the word is used correctly in a sentence. Hence our focus should be what is the true concept of the cell, rather than what we think nature should be, or what merely a mechanism should be. We must let go of our different biases and allow nature to reveal to us.
Why have we moved away from the logic of organic whole which was understood by philosophers like Kant, Hegel, Aristotle and Plato. Kant had even said that there will never be a Newton for the Blade of Grass. Then all of a sudden why the current shift of ontological thinking about the unity of the functional cell to a mechanical logic.
Why there is no result after more than 150 years attempts to manufacture even a single bacterium from de novo processes in our advanced chemical labs even after spending billions of dollars worth of time and manpower. What is the Causal principle behind the cellular function. Why is it still irreducible to linear simplicity. Cell continues to display circular complexity in its causal flow. So how can we accept the mechanical reduction of the organism.
Philosophical thought is often about frameworks and deeper principles, usually while inhabiting those frameworks and using those principles.
Philosophy is not merely an enterprise of finding answers via established methods and moving on. You are thinking about thinking while trying to think about questions that you have little idea how to answer. And this is hard. Really hard. As I often tell my students, if philosophy is not difficult, you’re not doing it right!
Gārgī is thinking about the fundamental nature of existence—what it could be, how we could know it, and whether we could put it into language even if we did know it. As important as philosophical debate has been and remains in India and elsewhere, you can’t always be worried about your next move in the debate. Sometimes you need to slow down and think rather than offer the first response that comes to mind.
I think this lesson could be especially important to people interacting online. There is a tendency to skim headlines, tweets, or blog posts and immediately rush to respond, but what if instead you thought silently before commenting? Often our initial gut reactions turn out to be wrong upon further reflection. A bit of silent thinking can help to sort out what to say and how to say it. It can help you to avoid misunderstanding others. It can get you immortalized in an Upaniṣad (at least that worked for Gārgī).
I will fall silent now so that you, dear readers, can think about this for yourselves. Cross-posted to my personal blog.
...
Dear Friends and Well-wishers, The seventh Subhash Kumar Mukherjee Memorial Oration, organized by Overman Foundation, was held on Friday, 20th December 2019, at Matru Sadan, in Pondicherry.
The speaker was Dr. Alok Pandey who spoke on the topic, “Why Do Bad Things Happen to Good People?”
...
Kundan Singh (HUM '08) will be giving a lecture at the Cultural Integration Fellowship entitled "Life and Legacy of the Mother of Sri Aurobindo Ashram." #fridaythoughts #CIISAlumni https://t.co/CJdqpxIxOg
https://twitter.com/ciisalumni/status/1231037861991813120?s=19
...
Economists should learn lessons from meteorologists
Weather forecasters make hypotheses and test them daily
https://t.co/5XnUD7OFKP
https://twitter.com/prasannavishy/status/1231082308645478401?s=19
Most economists (formally-trained as well as self-appointed) do macro forecasting of business cycles with fancy charts & high-sounding lingo in trendy conference halls & op-ed pages of newspapers! Ground-level realities are given a go by!
https://twitter.com/mayfair1958/status/1231084164797157377?s=19
Here is a detailed review of the book 'Galileo's Error' by Philip Goff @Philip_Goff Whether you agree with the author or not this book is important for those interested in consciousness studies and philosophy. https://t.co/AwQiyEnZD0 via @swarajyamag
https://twitter.com/arvindneela/status/1231039366157389826?s=19
In the review: It seems the Saiva Siddhanta scholars seem to have come up with a proto-variant of Mary-in-b&w realm. And Swami Vivekananda and Dr. Ambedkar had put forth an argument for ethics and democracy based on non-duality.
Akaramuthalvan In Ardhanarishvara: The Androgynous Link To Divinity And Language https://t.co/UrMzAMgTpn via @swarajyamag
https://twitter.com/prasannavishy/status/1230764907596877824?s=19
There is a category of challenges called tripāda-samasyās, which are tri-lined. This poses greater difficulty than others, for all 3 lines are disconnected, and are culled out from different poems.
Around Samasyā-pūraṇa: Analysing Literary Creativity - 9 https://t.co/AbmywW50Qk
https://twitter.com/prekshaajournal/status/1230540214919057410?s=19
One of the most fascinating tales in the Mahabharata is the dialogue between Yudhishtira and Yama on the banks of the enchanted pool. This episode is popularly known as the ‘Yakshaprashna.
Yakshaprashna: Quenching the Thirst - 1 https://t.co/mwCJ0YPwep
https://twitter.com/prekshaajournal/status/1230785009784479746?s=19
The Esoteric Sense of the Ashwamedha, the Horse Sacrifice https://t.co/zJbog54mC4
https://twitter.com/santoshk1/status/1230860209301663752?s=19
February 19, 2020
Heidegger’s philosophy lacked a sense of divine transcendence
- The Creation of Time - Sri Aurobindo translates Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, Chapter One, Section 2, Verse 4: “He desired, ‘Let a second self be born to me.’ He by mind had interc...
- COMING SOON: The 26th Savitri Study Camp - Savitri Study Camp No. 26 will be held from Feb. 22 to 28, 2020 at the Sri Aurobindo Society Beach Office, Pondicherry. The post COMING SOON: The 26th Sa...
- Flat Ontology, Questions, and Assemblages - I’ve been having a lengthy discussion with a very good friend about normativity and how we go about determining values. One of the things that keeps coming...
- Pranab Bardhan and Liberal Democracy's assless chaps. - India is not a Liberal Democracy. It is a Secular, Socialist, Republic. Its Constitution gives the Union of India substantial powers to curb any threat to ...
- Bādha from hermeneutics to epistemology - The chapter on epistemology (tarkapāda) is the first chapter in the basic text of Mīmāṃsā, the Mīmāṃsāsūtra, but was presumably the last one added to the M...
- Does the kammatic/nibbanic distinction fit the facts? - How helpful is Melford Spiro’s kammatic/nibbanic distinction in describing Buddhism? It can be tempting to line it up too closely … Continue reading →
- Blame it on the nature of politics - Hatred brigade includes many followers of Sri Aurobindo which is absurd but valid in a Democracy. Each person is a prisoner of his own circumstances, backg...
- Art for Land – String Quartet concert - On 2nd February we recorded an amazing performance held by the Auroville String quartet in Unity Pavilion. The quartet (Holger violin, Benjamin 2nd violin...
- media - Media: what a messy, capacious, contentious term, in all the ways Raymond Williams described for *Keywords*. Slipping across material substrate, technologi...
- The role of music in society - Sacred imagery: Human body as Veena - a musical instrument What we hold to be the highest ideals in life also dictate what we do in the humdrum of everyday...
- Reading the Qur’an: Repeated Reminders - [This semester, I am blogging my course on the Qur’an. You can see my previous post here and the whole series here.] We have now entered into what I consid...
- Pleasure and Pain in an Apocalyptic Age - The pursuit of pleasure and the avoidance of pain is part of the utilitarian creed that has characterised the Modern Age and the pursuit of the self-intere...
- “Why Do Bad Things Happen to Good People?”—A Talk by Dr. Alok Pandey - Dear Friends and Well-wishers, The seventh Subhash Kumar Mukherjee Memorial Oration, organized by Overman Foundation, was held on Friday, 20th December 201...
- Twilight of modern mind - - Savitri Era Devotees OM Is The Eternal Brahman - The Mandukya Upanishad, while relatively short, is focused entirely on an in depth examina...
- OM Is The Eternal Brahman - The Mandukya Upanishad, while relatively short, is focused entirely on an in depth examination of OM, in both its esoteric and its outward significance. O...
- Hampi Continues to Live – Part 7 - Continued from Part 6 Chakratirtha, Tungabhadra River and Kodandarama temple (Photos by Suhas Mehra, text by Beloo Mehra) Not far from Vittala temple, a ...
- Thoughts on William James, Pure Experience, and Materialism - Idealism and panpsychism seem to me to make easy friends in the debate against materialism. They both affirm that consciousness or experience or mind in so...
- Of India’s Destiny and Indian Painting - Going through the pictures of some of my personal favourite paintings representing various Indian schools and traditions, including some by famous Indian a...
- Bengali Writings by Sri Aurobindo (translated into English) - Most of the pieces in Bengali were written by Sri Aurobindo in 1909 and 1910 for Dharma, a Calcutta weekly he edited at that time; the material consists ...
February 07, 2020
Twilight of modern mind
- OM Is The Eternal Brahman - The Mandukya Upanishad, while relatively short, is focused entirely on an in depth examination of OM, in both its esoteric and its outward significance. O...
- Introduction to the Mandukya Upanishad: OM Is The Eternal Brahman - The Mandukya Upanishad, while relatively short, is focused entirely on an in depth examination of OM, in both its esoteric and its outward significance. O...
- Hampi Continues to Live – Part 7 - Continued from Part 6 Chakratirtha, Tungabhadra River and Kodandarama temple (Photos by Suhas Mehra, text by Beloo Mehra) Not far from Vittala temple, a ...
- Explorations in Savitri 156, pp. 372-374 - “O spirit, traveller of eternity, Who cam'st from the immortal spaces here Armed for the splendid hazard of thy life To set thy conquering foot on Chance a...
- Learning from Gārgī’s Silence - “Thereupon, Gārgī Vācaknavī fell silent.” (Bṛhadāraṇyaka Upaniṣad 3.6) I’m currently teaching a class called “Ancient Women Philosophers: India and Greece,...
- George Steiner's After Babel babble. - George Steiner is dead. I am now a dozen years older than he was when he published 'After Babel'. I can no longer believe that *'To understand is to deciph...
- Twilight of the Modern Mind - I have a book by Morris Berman entitled The Twilight of American Culture. I think it would have been better named The Twilight of the Modern Mind. This is ...
- Syllabus Help Request - I am teaching a newly designed course, Rhetoric & Dialogue in Religion & Theology (REL 300), which is part of a new sequence of courses running from our in...
- Thoughts on William James, Pure Experience, and Materialism - Idealism and panpsychism seem to me to make easy friends in the debate against materialism. They both affirm that consciousness or experience or mind in so...
- Kammatic and nibbanic Buddhism - Last winter my wife and I made a wonderful trip to Sri Lanka. Before I say anything about the trip’s … Continue reading →
- Of India’s Destiny and Indian Painting - Going through the pictures of some of my personal favourite paintings representing various Indian schools and traditions, including some by famous Indian a...
- belief - Scholars of religion generally agree that belief is a Western, Christian, and even Protestant construction that obscures more than illuminates the lives of...
- Shelley, Keats, and Savitri - Not many people knew him before he murdered Gandhi, nor he terrorised anyone. He had his patriotic conviction for the crime and was successful. One needn't...
- Mona Sarkar: In Memoriam by Anurag Banerjee - Mona Sarkar : In Memoriam Sixty years ago, on 18 January 1960, the Mother had narrated the fo...
- Bengali Writings by Sri Aurobindo (translated into English) - Most of the pieces in Bengali were written by Sri Aurobindo in 1909 and 1910 for Dharma, a Calcutta weekly he edited at that time; the material consists ...
- Seeking stops when ..... - Seeking and/or searching for meanings stop not only when we presume we know but also when we try to freeze the process through some of the following:- r...
- Yoga of Works: Practioners’ Experiences – M.S.Srinivasan - (A review and a commentary of the book Integral Yoga At Works, A Study of Practioners’ Experiences working in Four … Yoga of Works: Practioners’ Experience...
- How to invite intuitive knowledge - Sri Aurobindo was an Indian nationalist but is best known for his philosophy on human evolution and Integral Yoga.[87] Although Sri Aurobindo was familiar...
- Why pick on one person? - Probably the biggest damage done by the BJP-RSS fanboys is spreading total defeatism and negativity in Hindu ranks. They have thoroughly run down Hindu con...
- Shelley, Keats, and Savitri - Not many people knew him before he murdered Gandhi, nor he terrorised anyone. He had his patriotic conviction for the crime and was successful. One needn't...
- Dharma: Bengali weekly by Sri Aurobindo (1909-10) - Plasim Radar Sri Aurobindo Studies The Origin of Living Beings, Part Three–the Divisions of Time - Sri Aurobindo translates Prashna Upanishad, First Questi...
- Overman - a consciously evolving future human being - Transhumanism JM Gidley - Critical Terms in Futures Studies, 2019 … Synchronously, Indian political activist Sri *Aurobindo* conceived the notion of an “Ove...
- Hero is the one who can be betrayed with impunity - Assorted tweets collated by @NathTusar Director #SavitriEra Learning Forum (SELF since 2005) Ghaziabad #SriAurobindo #FiveDreams #WorldUnion Online Course...
- My original contributions to understanding Sri Aurobindo - My original contributions to understanding or interpreting Sri Aurobindo can be summarised under a number of heads: 1) Against Hindutva, Mythology, & Astro...