March 14, 2010

Millions of facts which in their entirety are not known to anybody


Hayek makes his claim that economics must augment the attention paid to the division of labor with an appreciation of the fragmentation of knowledge that entails, and also his claim that in advanced society it is not so much the knowledge that any one individual can acquire but the greater benefit that individuals can enjoy because of the knowledge possessed by others.  This is the Hayekian twist on the benefits of specialization and exchange and social cooperation under the division of labour.  For institutional analysis, we are led to ask what rules of the game and mechanisms of enforcement best serve to enable a society to realize the benefits of fragmented knowledge.
Consider the following passage from the beginning of chapter 1 in Vol. 1:
"This structure of human activities constantly adapts itself, and functions through adapting itself, to millions of facts which in their entirety are not known to anybody.  The significance of this process is most obvious and was at first stressed in the economic field.  As it has been said, 'the economic life of a non-socialist society consists of millions of relations or flows between individual firms and households.  We can establish certain theorems about them, but we can never observe all.'  The insight into the significance of our institutional ignorance in the economic sphere, and into the methods by which we have learnt to overcome this obstacle, was in fact the starting point for those ideas which in the present book are systematically applied to a much wider field.  It will be one of our chief contentions that most of the rules of conduct which govern our actions, and most of the institutions which arise out of this regularity, are adaptations to the impossibility of anyone taking conscious account of all the particular facts which enter into the order of society.  We shall see, in particular, that the possibility of justice rests on this necessary limitation of our factual knowledge, and that insight into the nature is therefore denied to all those constructivists who habitually argue on the assumption of omniscience." (p. 13)

To me this is an amazingly powerful passage and does set the stage for so much of what Hayek does in Vol. 2 and even in Vol. 3.  But it also points back to his work (at least in the 1930s) on knowledge and coping with our ignorance.  It also reflects, in my mind, how Hayek situates his work in the broader context of the cultural sciences and the disciplines of philosophy and political and moral theorizing. 

Unreasonable Reason from Cafe Hayek by Don Boudreaux
Here’s a letter that I sent to the Washington Post:

George Will wisely warns against reason unreasonably applied (“As a progressive, Obama hews to the Wilsonian tradition,” March 11).  Pres. Obama and his ilk are guided by an irrational faith that human reason is so potent and encompassing that it permits the Best and the Brightest to consciously design society, or at least to successfully rearrange significant parts of society (such as the health-care industry). 
This hubris is dangerous. F.A. Hayek, defending reason reasonably applied, wrote more than 60 years ago that
“the fundamental attitude of true individualism is one of humility toward the processes by which mankind has achieved things which have not been designed or understood by any individual and are indeed greater than individual minds.  The great question at this moment is whether man’s mind will be allowed to continue to grow as part of this process or whether human reason is to place itself in chains of its own making.  What individualism teaches us is that society is greater than the individual only in so far as it is free.  In so far as it is controlled or directed, it is limited to the powers of the individual minds which control or direct it.  If the presumption of the modern mind, which will not respect anything that is not consciously controlled by individual reason, does not learn in time where to stop, we may, as Edmund Burke warned us, ‘be well assured that everything about us will dwindle by degrees, until at length our concerns are shrunk to the dimensions of our minds.’” F.A. Hayek, “Individualism: True and False,” Chapter 1 of Hayek, Individualism and Economic Order (U. Chicago Press, 1948).



On Speaking In and Of Reality from One Cosmos by Gagdad Bob
I use the symbol "O" to stand for the infinite and unknowable ground of ultimate reality from which our existence is derived, the latter being like a spark thrown from a central fire. You are a spark in the dark responsible for that nasty business in the park, but that is a subject for a different post. O itself can never be known as it is. On the one hand, we can know "about" it, which I call (k), which refers to all of our profane, everyday knowledge up to and including the highest reaches of science. […]


We in the West suffer from a different problem than the one that afflicts so much of the (-n) Islamic world (mostly the unsufirabble parts). Unfortunately, our culture does more than honor (k). Rather, it elevates it to the highest. The secular world tries to eradicate O and replace it with mere (k), which automatically places one in an abstract, substitute, and counterfeit world at least one degree removed from reality.

Religions, properly understood, attempt to restore our primordial relationship to O. Fundamentally, they contemplate the holy and manifest mystery of Being by trying to enter it directly -- not talk about it but from within it. And when they do talk about the mystery, it is not in the manner of (k)-->O (or at least it shouldn't be). Rather, the direction is reversed, and it is O-->(n). 

March 13, 2010

The Mother, the central or integral Supramental Shakti and nobody else

Detachment and The Integral Yoga
by Debashish on Sat 07 Oct 2006 11:53 PM PDT  |  Permanent Link

Swadharma may be thought of as a law of self-becoming. In the Gita, Krishna says to Arjuna that it is much better to follow one’s own swadharma, even badly, than to be good at another’s swadharma. This issue is of great importance in the Gita because Arjuna is being exhorted to arise out of his despondency and take part in battle as a kshatriya. But though Swadharma can be a convenient starting point in our yoga, it is not something to be made a fetish of. Here, whatever one’s swadharma may be, it needs to be surrendered to The Mother because the Mother is the integral power of Becoming. Your central and psychic beings may have been born out of Mahakali but Sri Aurobindo is not asking you to make your surrender to Mahakali or to istadevi. He is asking you to surrender to The Mother. The reason is that she is the integral power of Becoming. She not only integrates you and brings the other powers into action in your life, she is also integrating the entire universe, because she knows what to bring into your consciousness and when, in a harmonious fashion so as to create a coordinated universal growth towards the supramental manifestation.
The supramental life is one in which All is one and yet each is different - but it is governed by the Oneness. The power which controls the supramental consciousness is the integral power of The Mother – Aditi, the central circle in the Mother’s symbol. This is what we are called to make our surrender to.
The Action of the Four Powers of The Mother
The four Mahashaktis of The Mother are all supramental powers in their origin, so each is active on all the parts of the being, though it may have a more concentrated expression in one part. This is just as in the case of the modes of Prakriti, the gunas - sattwa, rajas and tamas. Tamas is more settled in the physical, rajas is more settled in the vital, satwa is more settled in the mind, but each is active in the entire nature. It is similar with the action of the four Mahashaktis – Maheshwari acts more characteristically through the mind, Mahakali more through the vital, the higher vital, the will part of the vital, Mahalakshami acts more through the emotional part of the vital and Mahasaraswati acts more predominantly though the physical being, developing and expressing its skills. But, at the same time, each is active on all four parts of the being. So it isn’t really possible to isolate their action in any one part of the being though there is a certain centrality of action. There is an action centered in one of these parts of the being depending on the swadharma. Children of Maheshwari are the Brahmins, Children of Mahakali are the Kshatriyas, Children of Mahalakshmi are the Vaishyas, Children of Mahasaraswati are the Sudras. So the central being will locate itself accordingly, and the psychic being will take on a specific quality accordingly.
Growth and Transformation of the Psychic Being
But whatever the quality expressed by the psychic being, it is also potentially of infinite quality. Behind the psychic being is the psychic entity and the psychic entity is a portion of the original integral Mother, Aditi, Para Prakriti, the central Supramental Shakti. Thus it is capable of brining forth from its own potential, powers of the Mother which are unexpressed in its present constitution. It can constantly transform itself under the guidance and action of the Supreme Mother. This transformation of the psychic being is at the center of the Integral Yoga of Sri Aurobindo and the Mother. Sri Aurobindo speaks of the Integral Yoga in terms of what he calls the Triple Transformation. Ultimately, this triple transformation is accomplished through the growth and transformation of the psychic being. The first transformation is the transformation of the inner and outer nature by the power of the psychic, the psychicisation – the coming to the front of the psychic being and its recasting of the mind, life and body into its own principle. The second transformation is the cosmic or spiritual transformation. Here it is the psychic being that must unite and identify itself with the Cosmic or Universal Being, with what Sri Aurobindo has called the Overmind. The psychic purusha must become one with the Overmental Purusha and transform the nature by the power of the Overmental Shakti. And finally, the third transformation is the supramental transformation. And here it is the psychic being that has to become supramentalized. The psychic purusha must unite and identify itself with the Supramental Purusha and transform the entire nature by the power of the Supramental Shakti. The Mother says that the psychic being holds the key to supramentalization. And it is a supramentalized psychic being that in its physical aspect can bring down the Supermind into the cells of the body.
So the key to this very complex growth and transformation of the psychic being is in the hands of The Mother, the central or integral Supramental Shakti and nobody else. None of the emanated Powers of the Mother can do it. They can be deployed by her to do it. Into our lives she brings these powers. We are put through various experiences in which various powers of the Mother aid us, act on us, act through us in our journey. But the central granter, the giver of the yoga and its movements, its circumstances, its inner and outer growth is the Mother, the supreme Mother at the transcendent centre and origin of the manifestation.
Let us end with a meditation.
Debashish Banerji
Foundation Course for Facilitators (16.08.06 : At Van Nivas, Nainital)
Re: Sri Aurobindo’s Marriage—a discussion by Raman Reddy pertaining to a few aspects in context of the latest biography published by the Columbia University Press
by Raman Reddy, V. on Wed 10 Mar 2010 01:36 PM IST |  Profile |  Permanent Link Dear Auroman, 
I was, of course, speaking in the context of this particular debate when I said that Indian disciples of Sri Aurobindo should awaken their intellects to take on the challenge that is coming from the West. The challenge is also how to integrate the best of Western culture with the best of the East, or rather spirituality with intellect and science. The problem comes up when there are acute differences on the nature of this integration. The question that comes up is whether the intellect should be subsumed to the higher power or whether spirituality should be merely considered for an interesting study (without really practising it), so that you start drawing all sorts of ignorant conclusions based on your surface understanding. I am not against intellectual study per se, because even as I make this comment, I am exercising my intellect. But there is an inherent limitation of the mind with regard to the deeper aspects of our being, which we should always keep at the back of our minds while using the mind. 

March 11, 2010

What will lead the humanity is not the geographical India, nor the historical India

Undoubtedly, India is the oldest civilization that is still living. And it will live on, as the very essence of India’s message is to lead the World, lead the humanity towards the Supreme Truth, the Supreme Realization.
But what will lead the humanity and the World to the grand and brilliant Future is not the geographical
India, nor the historical India, as it is known externally, but the very true inner Spirit of India…
According to Sri Aurobindo and The Mother, Moksha or Nirvana is not the Task before us, though that may come on our way. We need not or should not return to the Origin. Nor should we continue as the ordinary human beings, immersed in the clay and mud of Darkness, Ignorance, Inertia, in the blind animal nature and activities, in the lower vital passions and movements, in the atmosphere of jealousy, hatred, betrayal, enmity, clashes and feuds. Man has a long march ahead to be taken up, so that the new Supramental Race reigns upon earth. The Goal, as taught by Sri Aurobindo and The Mother, is to evolve into a New Being, the Supramental Being, as the New Consciousness, the Supramental Consciousness, has already descended on earth and has been active by now.
The only rational and sensible solution seems to be this: If Sri Aurobindo has written something himself, just restore it… If something can be done to restore the original 1951 and 1954 editions (the ones the Mother read from when she ...
[Savitri Era of those who adore, Om Sri Aurobindo & The Mother.] Director, Savitri Era Learning Forum. [SELF posits a model of counselling and communicative action as an instrument in order to stimulate the public sphere. ...
Foremost among these were the Indian philosopher-sage Sri Aurobindo, the French philosopher Henri Bergson, and the French paleontologist and Catholic priest Pierre Teilhard de Chardin. Other key figures included the American essayist . ...
By chance, when I showed up in Pondicherry in February, it was the 50th anniversary of Mirra's founding of the Sri Aurobindo Society, which is devoted to propagating the ideas of her close spiritual collaborator, the Indian freedom ...
Comment posted by: Kepler
Sri Aurobindo in certain places in his writings references the state of rational knowledge and thought at that time. Since then there have been further developments, e.g. postmodernism in the humanities, the micro and neural biological revolutions in the sciences, the European Union in politics. Presumably if Sri Aurobindo were writing today he might have some comment on those developments. Likewise readers today who are versed in those developments might react differently to certain references in Sri Aurobindo's writings than a reader would have 100 years ago. Someone intellectually capable might be able to address such developments from an Aurobindonian perspective - and there might be some value in that.

March 10, 2010

Faith in your essential greatness and beauty

Amazon.com: 50 Self-Help Classics: 50 Inspirational Books to Transform Your Life ~ Tom Butler-Bowdon A brilliant introduction to the "literature of possibility", September 21, 2005
By       Robert Morris (Dallas, Texas) - See all my reviews

In both this volume and in 50 Success Classics, Butler-Bowdon has selected and then provided a rigorous examination of carefully selected works which have had, for decades, a profound impact on those who read them and then applied the principles which their respective authors affirm. In this instance, inspiration and guidance to transform one's life. There are several reasons why I hold this volume in such high regard. Here are three.

First, Butler-Bowdon has assembled excerpts and focused on key points from a wide variety of works which include (with authors listed in alphabetical order, as in the book), Marcus Aurelius' Meditations, Robert Bly's Iron John, Joseph Campbell with Bill Moyers' The Power of Myth, Dale Carnegie's How to Win Friends and Influence People, the Dalai Lama and Howard C. Cutler's The Art of Happiness, Wayne Dyer's Real Magic, Ralph Waldo Emerson's Self-Reliance, Benjamin Franklin's Autobiography, Lao Tzu's Tao Te Ching, Abraham Maslow's Motivation and Personality, Thomas Moore's Care of the Soul, Joseph Murphy's The Power of Your Subconscious Mind, Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged, and Henry David Thoreau's Walden. Obviously, some of this material would also be appropriate for inclusion in 50 Success Classics.

Second, I appreciate the fact that Butler-Bowdon also enables his readers to focus on specific themes of greatest interest to them by suggesting combinations of selections as follows:

The Power of Thought: Change your thoughts, change your life
Following Your Dream: Achievement and goal setting
Secrets of Happiness: Doing what you love, doing what works
The Bigger Picture: Keeping it in perspective
Soul and Mystery: Appreciating your depth
Making a Difference: Transforming yourself, transforming the world

The diversity of Butler-Bowdon's primary sources is indeed impressive even when grouped according to a common theme.

Third and finally, he makes clever use of a number of reader-friendly devices throughout his narrative, such as "In a nutshell," "Final comments," and a brief bio of the author at the conclusion of each selection. I also appreciate the inclusion of brief quotations wherever they are most relevant.

In the Introduction, Butler-Bowdon observes that a self-help book "can be your best friend and champion, expressing a faith in your essential greatness and beauty that is sometimes hard to get from another person. Because of its emphasis on following your star and believing that your thoughts can remake your world, a better name for self-help writing might be the `literature of possibility.' Many people are amazed that the self-help sections in bookstores are so huge. For the rest of us, there is no mystery. Whatever recognizes our right to dream, then shows us how to make the dream a reality, is powerful and valuable."

What he offers is by no means a buffet of motivational "hors d'oeuvres."  On the contrary, the content selected is solid and skillfully presented within an appropriate context. I am convinced that many of those who read this book will be encouraged to read (or re-read) many of the primary sources in their entirety. Permalink
  SELF-HELP CLASSICS
 1.         James Allen As a Man Thinketh (1904)
2.       S Andreas & C Faulkner (eds) NLP: The New Technology of Achievement (1996)
3.       Marcus Aurelius Meditations (2ndC)
4.       Martha Beck Finding Your Own North Star (2001)
5.       The Bhagavad-Gita
6.       The Bible
7.       Robert Bly Iron John (1990)
8.       Boethius The Consolation of Philosophy (6thC)
9.       Alain de Botton How Proust Can Change Your Life (1997)
10.     William Bridges Transitions: Making Sense of Life's Changes(1980)
11.      David D Burns The New Mood Therapy (1980)
12.     Joseph Campbell (with Bill Moyers) The Power of Myth (1988)
13.     Richard Carlson Don't Sweat The Small Stuff (1997)
14.     Dale Carnegie How to Win Friends and Influence People(1936)
15.     Deepak Chopra The Seven Spiritual Laws of Success (1994)
16.     Paulo Coelho The Alchemist (1988)
17.     Stephen Covey The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People (1989)
18.     Mihaly Cziksentmihalyi Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience (1991)
19.     Alain de Botton How Proust Can Change Your Life (1997)
20.    The Dalai Lama & Howard Cutler The Art of Happiness (1999)
21.     The Dhammapada (Buddha's teachings)
22.    Wayne Dyer Real Magic (1992)
23.    Ralph Waldo Emerson Self-Reliance (1841)
24.    Clarissa Pinkola Estes Women Who Run With The Wolves(1996)
25.    Viktor Frankl Man's Search For Meaning (1959)
26.    Benjamin Franklin Autobiography (1790)
27.    Shakti Gawain Creative Visualization (1982)
28.    Daniel Goleman Emotional Intelligence (1995)
29.    John Gray Men Are From Mars, Women Are From Venus(1992)
30.    Louise Hay You Can Heal Your Life (1984)
31.     James Hillman The Soul's Code: In Search of Character and Calling (1996)
32.    Susan Jeffers Feel The Fear And Do It Anyway (1987)
34.    Lao-Tzu Tao-te Ching (The Way of Power)
35.    Maxwell Maltz Psycho-Cybernetics (1960)
36.    Abraham Maslow Motivation and Personality (1954)
37.    Philip C McGraw Life Strategies: Doing What Works, Doing What Matters (2000)
38.    Thomas Moore Care of the Soul (1992)
39.    Joseph Murphy The Power of Your Subconscious Mind (1963)
40.    Norman Vincent Peale The Power of Positive Thinking (1952)
41.     Carol Pearson The Hero Within (1989)
42.    M Scott Peck The Road Less Traveled (1990)
43.    Ayn Rand Atlas Shrugged (1957)
44.    Anthony Robbins Awaken The Giant Within (1991)
45.    Florence Scovell-Shinn The Game of Life and How To Play It(1923)
46.    Martin Seligman Learned Optimism (1991)
47.    Samuel Smiles Self-Help (1859)
48.    Pierre Teilhard de Chardin The Phenomenon of Man (1955)
49.    Henry David Thoreau Walden (1854)
50.    Marianne Williamson A Return To Love (1993)

March 08, 2010

Every form and color related to the dire struggle for existence


Real study is political work. Example: Lenin spent his darkest political winter preparing, preparing, preparing to launch what would become a singularity in history, a proletarian revolution, and how? By studying Hegel. Not by learning how to be a Hegelian, but by learning from and against Hegel, reading critically, reading like a grownup and not a devotee. Do that.

Yes, it is true that life is unsatisfying. The biological world is not fair. The social world, families and nations and relationships, need not be so unfair as they are today. Work toward a fair and kind world.


Eric Hoffer in his book The True Believer makes an irrefutable point in saying that an essential aspect of any mass movement (e.g., Islamism, fascism, communism, socialism etc. etc.) is that it spreads by encouraging utopian fantasies and promises of future societal bliss. In order to succeed, all such movements must have followers who are "true believers" through and through; and, as the annointed ones, they are eager and willing to sacrifice themselves (and often many others) for the sake of their cause.

As people become unhappy and dissatisfied with their lives, they become succeptible to anyone and any group who makes vague promises of the "hope and change" kind. […] And, Sowell noticed back in 2008 that many of the followers of Barack Obama were 'true believers' who had attached themselves to the ultimate "political busybody" who was going to--by force of his incredible personality--heal the planet; bring hope to the hopeless; and change to the world, leading us into a glorious future. […]

So there was President Obama, giving his bazillionth speech on health care, droning yet again that "now is the hour when we must seize the moment," the same moment he's been seizing every day of the week for the past year, only this time his genius photo-op guys thought it would look good to have him surrounded by men in white coats. 

Michael Marder on the task ahead.

In lieu of prescribing an easy way to overcome the problem of modernity, Husserlian reduction and Heideggerian de-formalization impose the exigency of a patient, if not Sisyphean, theoretical and practical work of removing layers of sedimentation that are bound to re-grow, given that their accumulation constitutes the movement of history.

Rather than peeling the layers off the historical onion, use a sharp knife to slice through them. There will be less tears in the end. 

John Searle on Derrida's mistake.

Now, in the twentieth century, mostly under the influence of Wittgenstein and Heidegger, we have come to believe that this general search for these sorts of foundations is misguided. There aren't in the way classical metaphysicians supposed any foundations for ethics or knowledge. For example, we can't in the traditional sense found language and knowledge on "sense data" because our sense data are already infused with our linguistic and social practices. Derrida correctly sees that there aren't any such foundations, … From The New York Review of Books review "The Word Turned Upside Down".

I went to the market today. At the news kiosk I picked up the Feb. 26 Times Literary Supplement. The TLS has a commentary by Lesley Chamberlain on "Heidegger through post-Darwinian eyes".

She argues that Darwin's influence on Heidegger is under appreciated because when we read translations of Heidegger's German the similarities are unapparent to us, but in German Heidegger is using the same vocabulary as the German translation of The Origin of the Species. Half of the essay is on the German art world's reaction to Darwinism, and The Origin of the Work of Art.

[T]here were two driving ideas behind that lecture. One suggested that works of art, defined as the truth-at-work-in-the-work, cast a special light on Being. It followed from this that art, and beauty, and the truth of the work, should be considered in a sphere other than traditional aesthetics. After Darwin, who showed that the mind and the moral sense had also evolved and did not come divinely equipped with a sense of beauty, truth and goodness, both the moral worth of high art and the category of category of beauty were radically disrupted. Darwin showed that "every form and color that man chose to find beautiful, from the spirals of a shell to the blooms of an insect-pollinated flower, were the effects of 'secondary laws'. . . related to the dire struggle for existence".

And so Heidegger could say aesthetics was another set of beliefs left with no ground to stand on. Beauty did not relate to an impulse of delight the Creator wished to share with mankind. Nor did it have, for Darwin at least, a "higher" meaning. Heidegger gave art a meaning, to allow a glimpse of Being, but he showed a wilful lack of interest in art's human creators. Look again at what Darwin was accused of from the side of the humanities: we can see how closely it matches the negative view of Heidegger that prevailed in many circles to the end of he twentieth century. "The subversive tendency. . . challenged the whole basis of traditional thinking about the beauty of the creation".

Evolutionary theory, which gave beauty a subordinate use in the struggle to sustain emergence, removed the moral privilege of the work of art, and the moral and the social status of those who claimed it as the vehicle for universal truths. The impact of Darwin's undoing of classical aesthetics was democratic and particuliarizing and localizing, and he was rightly accused of undoing high culture; as Heidegger seems to do.

March 02, 2010

Sri Aurobindo's theory of history and evolution in time & Hegel's

Another lacuna in the scholarship:

What, precisely, is the relationship of Aurobindo's theory of history and evolution in time to Hegel's, and to German idealism generally? This question demands a close reading of the relevant texts, of course, but it also calls for a historical treatment (not merely a comparative "Both these Great Men were Great Men of Great Genius!... stating the obvious for its cult value and not really bringing any knowledge to the table).
[Aside: "cult value" in this sense is not meant as a dismissal, just as a mark of irrelevance to the questions I am trying to get at here. Savitri as a religious object has much legitimate cult value; the nature of that cult value is an interesting scholarly question, but the scholarship should not only be cultish in the sense of being an uncritical Hooray for Savitri! sense. Similarly, the Cult of Great Men model of historiography has long been discredited, but some in this neighborhood still persist in it in their academic writing. Cut it out, friends, and try to think critically about these things.]


Back to Aurobindo and Hegel. Writers like Ken Wilber tend to feign surprise that so many writers in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries working the "spirituality and metaphysics" assembly line seem to agree with each other. Is it so surprising that Hegel should betray the influence of Spinoza, given that Hegel had obviously read Spinoza? No, only a complete innocence of European history would lead one to be surprised, or even to make such a claim as if it has meaning.

I have suggested in the past that Aurobindo's theory of history has its origins more in European idealism than it has in traditional Indic sources, on the basis of the Hegelian traces in his writings. How to explain these traces? I cannot prove that Aurobindo read Hegel's Philosophy of Right. He may well have; he may not have. It is an open question. However, there is no question that Hegelian ideas permeated the intellectual culture in which Aurobindo was educated in England. He could not have avoided it if he tried. I. A. Richards. Whether or not Hegel exerted a direct influence on Aurobindo's thinking on history, there is no question that this mediated, Anglicized form of Hegelianism must have.

But these claims are really very tentative and exploratory in nature. I very much look forward to a systematic and rigorous treatment of this question. To the point, I look forward to the complete obsolescence of my own work on Aurobindo.

A disappointing experiment: review the recent scholarship (2005 and onward) on Aurobindo's great poem, Savitri. A quick keyword search reveals so little of critical substance, and so much of a speculative castles-in-the-clouds variety, or worse.

Savitri rewards multiple readings. It is a product of an interesting (and well-documented) time and place. There is a paucity of useful scholarship on it. For these reasons and others, it seems a very good object for a dissertation in English Lit or Cultural Studies. The hyperbolic claims made on its behalf by certain of its partisans (making of the text a cult object) constitute another question entirely.  10:02 AM


Now, why is this question on the relationship between Aurobindo's historiography and Hegel's philosophy of right (in which Spirit is determinative of changes in history, culminating in an authoritarian State) significant?

It gets at the broader question of how knowledge is made in Integral Studies circles (insofar as it constitutes some of the presuppositions of professed integral writers, Ken Wilber in the front row of these). It also suggests some possibilities for critique. How relevant to Aurobindo and those who effectively profit from his intellectual labors (again, Wilber in the front row) are materialist or at least non-idealist critiques of Hegel's historiography, and the political consequences of that historiography, for instance? Where there is earnest critique, there is a possibility to advance, to move forward, instead of retreating into the comfortable.

To give some context on this, consider the case of Sean Kelly's book on Jung and Hegel (Kelly is an important figure at the California Institute of Integral Studies, an explicitly Aurobindian institution where a lot of important work is getting done). Kelly finds that Jung and Hegel agree on a number of things, and that where they differ, contemporary readers can learn from those differences too. Now, Jung surely read Hegel, and was exposed to different forms of post-Hegelian idealism throughout his lifetime. So there is a material basis for finding these claims very plausible. There is a conceptual basis for the same: both Jung and Hegel are idealists, and as idealists, any difference between them will not be fundamental but will express differences over how the ideal is expressed: an internal debate.

Now, how does this project constitute a good fit with CIIS? Aurobindian thought is without reservation idealistic. The CIIS pedagogy? Idealistic. The culture? A new-age redaction of post-Hegelian evolutionism mixed with a new-age redaction of post-Jungian romantic hero-journey collective consciousness far out man. This may sound dismissive, but I do not think it is unfair. If it is dismissive, it is dismissive of certain intellectual mistakes made at a certain time, not dismissive of the people who made them or the institution at which those mistakes were made. Again, the only way to move forward is to recognize past and current errors and correct them. My point is that Sean Kelly's book on Jung and Hegel, conceived and researched if not completely written before he was hired at CIIS if I understand correctly, is a good example of how this nexus between Hegel and Aurobindo is constitutive of how knowledge is made in the world of Integral Studies. Therefore, some critical and objective understanding of this nexus would constitute a useful advance for integral studies.


I am fascinated with the case of Vitvan and his School of the Natural Order. I bring it up again because of its relevance to the question of Aurobindo and new age culture in the US, as well as whatever it is we currently call integral studies.

Specifically, Vitvan's doctrine and practice anticipated much of Aurobindo's mature work. Vitvan, as near as I can tell, did not have significant knowledge of Aurobindo's work until his own was well established, in fact crystallized from many of the same sources as Aurobindo himself had been exposed to (Shaktism, European idealism, post-Victorian bric a brac on race, Theosophy, &c). So: how best to characterize this? How to understand Vitvan's role in the formation of the human potential movement in North America, his contribution to new age culture, and his near absence in contemporary discussions of the same? How to understand his oeuvre vis a vis Aurobindo's?

More personally, I would love to visit the Home Farm. Some places are sacred. Some of those places are in the North American West. This may be one of those places. Look at these mountains. Those images make me homesick, longing to get away from the east and back home to the west. But I digress.