March 25, 2010

Always our Captain holds the rudder well, He does not sleep

On the one hand, at the core of my onticology is the thesis that objects are powers of acting, and thus are better thought as verbs and perhaps events, than nouns. When Spinoza asks, in book 3 of the Ethics, what can a body do?, I want to take this question seriously and treat bodies as doings. Objects Act from Larval Subjects

I most immediately thought of Lewis Mumford’s wonderful bit comparing Ralph Waldo Emerson and Melville:
“Emerson was the perpetual passenger who stayed below in bad weather, trusting that the captain would take care of the ship.  Melville was the sailor who climbed aloft, and knew that the captain was sometimes drunk and that the best of ships might go down.” “Ecstasies before bunnies’ burrows” from An und für sich by Brad Johnson

About twenty four hours have passed since President Obama signed the horrible socialistic & nazi-rrific health care bill into law. And you know what? Armageddon is awfully late in coming. Where is God coming to smite the land? Where are the death panels coming to take Granny away? 
I am beginning to suspect that the communist-muslimistic takeover of All Things American has gone so far as to include the Marxist-ization of the Rapture. The reds got that too! (title unknown) from For The Turnstiles by DGA

As it pertains to Obama, the really frightening thing about him is his "superior ignorance," but especially his conspicuous ignorance of that which he blindly opposes. For example, his long-time membership in that racist, anti-American religious sect can only mean that he must take this diseased Marxist aberration for normative Christianity. But I think the real source of Obama's ignorance is that he is our first postmodern president. […] Linear-thinking Leftists never understand the non-linear system of incentives they are putting in place when they enact complex legislation, so they inevitably must introduce more legislation to deal with those baleful consequences. Never forget that the government programs of the 1960s were sold as a way to end poverty, not to make it a permanent feature to justify the need for more big government. See What Happens, Barry, When You F*ck a Stranger in the Ass? from One Cosmos by Gagdad Bob

Yesterday, I had quoted Thomas Paine’s Common Sense (1776) on how “society” and “government” are two different things, and how some people, even in his day, had confused the two. This is what is happened in India in 1947, and is continuing today. Society has to feed itself, through production and exchange, in The Free Market. Throw Out This Government from ANTIDOTE by Sauvik

In Moral Sentiments, the object of the metaphor of ‘an invisible hand’ is the absolute necessity, whatever the ‘unfeeling’ landlord’s lack of concern for his ‘brethren’, for him to provide subsistence for his ‘toilers’.
In Wealth Of Nations the object of the metaphor of ‘an invisible hand’ is the absolute unavoidable consequence of those merchants who invest at home, for whatever reason, including their risk-avoidance, of their adding to aggregate national output (and thereby employment of labour), which in terms of ‘spreading opulence’ is a public benefit. On Misleading Humanities Students from Adam Smith's Lost Legacy by Gavin Kennedy

That is the new book by David Schmidtz and Jason Brennan.  It is ideal for anyone looking for a broad overview of human history from a classical liberal point of view.  Self-recommending, as they say.  Buy it here.  Here areSchmidtz and Brennan on CatoUnbound. from Marginal Revolution by Tyler Cowen

Chris, a loyal MR reader, asks: I'd like to see you list the top 10 books which have influenced your view of the world. I'll go with the "gut list," rather than the "I've thought about this for a long time list."  I'll also stress that books are by no means the only source of influence.  The books are in no intended order, although the list came out in a broadly chronological stream:
1. Plato, Dialogues.  I read these very early in life and they taught me about trying to think philosophically and also about meta-rationality.
2. The Incredible Bread Machine, by Susan Love Brown, et.al.  This was the first book I ever read on economics and it got me excited about the topic.
3. Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal, by Ayn Rand.  This got me excited about the idea that production is what matters and that producers must have the freedom and incentives to operate.
4. Friedrich A. Hayek, Individualism and Economic Order.  The market as a discovery procedure and why socialist calculation will not succeed.  (By the way, I'll toss a chiding tsk-tsk the way of Wolfers and Thoma.)
5. John Maynard Keynes: The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money.  Keynes is one of the greatest thinkers of economics and there are new ideas on virtually every page.
6. John Stuart Mill, Autobiography.  This got me thinking about how one's ideas change, and should change, over the course of a lifetime.  Plus Mill is a brilliant thinker and writer more generally.
7. Willard van Orman Quine, Word and Object.  This is actually a book about how to arrive at a deeper understanding than the one you already have, although I suspect few people read it that way.
8. Reasons and Persons, by Derek Parfit.  This convinced me that a strictly individualistic approach to ethics will not in general succeed and introduced me to new ways of reasoning and new ways to plumb for depth.
9. Camille Paglia, Sexual Personae.  I don't think the ideas in this book have influenced me very much, but reading it was, for whatever reason, the impetus to start writing about the economics of culture and also to give a broader focus to what I write.  Alex, by the way, was the one who recommended it to me.
10. Marcel Proust, Remembrance of Things Past.  This is still the best book on interiority.
I'd also like to mention the two books by Fischer Black, although a) I cannot easily elevate one over the other, and b) I capped the list at ten.  La Rochefoucauld's Maxims also deserves honorary mention, on self-deception and related issues.  Plus there is Shakespeare -- also for thinking with depth -- although I cannot point to a single book above the others.  Harold Bloom's The Western Canon comes to mind as well.
I would encourage other bloggers to offer similar lists. from Marginal Revolution by Tyler Cowen

March 23, 2010

Sri Aurobindo, K.C. Bhattacharyya and Radhakrishnan

Anie Nunnally The Golden Path: Interviews with Disciples of Sri Aurobindo and The Mother from the Sri Aurobindo Ashram and Auroville Anie Nunnally (Paperback - Jan 1, 2004), Rainbow Bridge: A Comparative Study of Tagore and Sri Aurobindo Goutam Ghosal (Hardcover - Feb 2, 2007, Netaji Subhas Confronted the Indian Ethos (1900-1921): Yogi Sri Aurobindo's " Terrorism " , Poet Tagore's " Universalism " , and Mahatma Gandhi's " Experimental Non-Violence " Adwaita P. Ganguly (Hardcover - Sep 5, 2003), Vision of India Rabindranath Tagore, Swami Vivekananda, Mahatma Gandi, Sri Aur…, Among the great;: Conversations with Romain Rolland, Mahatma Gandhi, Bertrand Russell, Rabindranath Tagore [and] Sri Aurobindo Dilip Kumar Roy, Four Indo-Anglian poets: Study of Toru Dutt, Rabindra Nath Tagore, Sri Aurobindo and Sarojini Naidu A. N Dwivedi, Indian Religions: A Historical Reader of Spiritual Experience and Expression (Paperback - Feb 1, 2002), Lover's Gift and Crossing: "The Romance of a Mystic" (Living Time Nobel Prize Collection) Rabindranath Tagore, Sri Aurobindo (Paperback - Sep 4, 2006), Sri Aravinda aura Mahatma Gandhi ke darsanom ka samikshatmaka adhyayana Pratibha Srivastav, Contemporary Indian idealism: (with special reference to Swami Vivekananda, Sri Aurobindo and Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan Ripusudan Prasad Srivastava, Concepts of reason and intuition: (with special reference to Sri Aurobindo, K.C. Bhattacharyya and Radhakrishnan) Ramesh Chandra Sinha, The ideal of world community: Buddhist aspiration in view of Sri Aurobindo Hajime Nakamura, The Meeting of the East and the West in Sri Aurobindo's Philosophy S.K. Maitra, Sri Aurobindo on Philosophy of Yoga Satyajyoti Chakravorty (Hardcover - Oct 31, 1997), Sri Aurobindo: A Contemporary Reader, The Concept of Personality in Sri Aurobindo's Integral Yoga Psychology and A. Maslow's Humanistic/Transpersonal Psychology Joseph Vrinte (Hardcover - Sep 1995), Integral Advaitism of Sri Aurobindo Ram Shankar Misra (Hardcover - Jul 1, 1998), Sri Aurobindo, Jung and Vedic Yoga Satya Prakash Singh (Hardcover - Apr 15, 2005), Sri Aurobindo and Karl Marx: Integral Sociology and Dialectical Sociology D. P. Chattopadhyaya (Hardcover - Dec 1, 1991), Understanding Thoughts of Sri Aurobindo Sanyal; INdrani and Krishna Roy (Hardcover - Feb 2, 2007), Perennial Quest for a Psychology with a Soul: An inquiry into the relevance of Sri Aurobindo's metaphysical yoga psychology in the context of Ken Wilber's integral psychology Joseph Vrinte (Hardcover - Jan 1, 2002), The philosophy of Sri Aurobindo in the light of the Gospel (Indian research series) Eva Olsson, Integral Consciousness: Sri Aurobindo's Yoga and how Haridas Chaudhuri brought it to the West Mark Kitchell (DVD), Indias rebirth: Out of the ruins of the West : a selection from Sri Aurobindos writings, talks and speeches Aurobindo Ghose (Paperback - Jan 1, 1997), Dante and Sri Aurobindo: A Comparative Study of "The Divine Comedy" and "Savitri" Prema Nandakumar, Mental Plane: Hermeticism, Theosophy, Rosicrucianism, Sri Aurobindo, New Age, Plane (esotericism), Reality, Thought, Western World, Secularism. (Paperback - Jan 6, 2010), Sri Aurobindo and the theories of evolution;: A critical and comparative study of the Indian and western theories of evolution with special reference to ... evolution (The Chowkhamba Sanskrit studies) Rama Shanker Srivastava, A Greater Psychology: An Introduction to the Psychological Thought of Sri Aurobindo Sri Aurobindo (Hardcover - Jan 15, 2001), Eckhart Tolle Sri Aurobindo A.S. Dalal (Paperback - Dec 1, 2008), Les Ecrits Bengalis De Sri Aurobindo [1972-1950] Prithwindra Mukherjee, Sri Aurobindo's Political Thought Haridas; Mukherjee, Uma Mukherjee (Hardcover - Jan 1, 1958), From Man Human to Man Divine: Sri Aurobindo's Vision of the Evolutionary Destiny of Man Jugal Kishore Mukherjee (Hardcover - Feb 1990), The Destiny Of The Body/The Vision and the Realisation in Sri Aurobindo's Yoga Jugal Kishore Mukherjee (Paperback - Jan 1, 2000), Sri Aurobindo: The Smiling Master Jugal Kishore Mukherjee (Paperback - Dec 1995), The ascent of sight in Sri Aurobindo's Savitri Jugal Kishore Mukherjee, Sri Aurobindo's Poetry and Sanskrit Rhetoric Jugal K. Mukherjee (Paperback - Dec 31, 1990), Bande Mataram' and Indian Nationalism (1906-1908). Being a study in theideas of India's First Freedom Movement based on those rare editorialarticles of Sri Audobindo and Bepin Chandra Pal which first appeared inthe famous "Bande Mataram" daily between 1906 and 1908. Uma; Haridas Mukherjee Mukherjee (Paperback - Jan 1, 1957), Sri Aurobindo Ashram - Its Role, Responsibility and Future Destiny: An Insider's Personal View Jugal Kishore Mukherjee (Paperback - Aug 1, 1997), Sri Aurobindo Prithwindra Mukherjee (Paperback - Feb 18, 2000), Economics Natural or Integral Economics J.N. Mukherjee (Hardcover - Dec 31, 1987), India's Freedom Struggle, 1857-1947 Peter Heehs (Hardcover - Dec 1988), Quest for Freedom: The United States and India's Independence Kenton J. Clymer (Hardcover - Oct 15, 1995), Bharat Mata: Calendar Art and India's Freedom Struggle Erwin Neumayer, Christine Schelberger (Hardcover - Jan 14, 20…, India's Freedom Reassessed: The Legacy of the Desais And Patels of Gujarat Chittaranjan Dadubhai, Dr. Desai (Hardcover - Jun 30, 2007)

March 21, 2010

The conscious role we can play and lay as the lynch-pin

We have completed our review of book 1 of the Life Divine, “Omnipresent Reality and the Universe”. This first book provides the overview and presents us with the vast sweep of the process of involution of consciousness and the subsequent evolution. It provides us a view of the gradations of consciousness and how they inter-relate to one another; and it provides us with the understanding of the necessity of the world of dualities as a result of the exclusive concentration that permits each potentiality to work itself out as if independent of all other possibilities.
Book 2 of the Life Divine is divided into two sections. Book 2, Part 1, “The Infinite Consciousness and the Ignorance” goes into detail to provide precise knowledge that we can utilize to consciously begin to participate in the evolutionary action. We might consider this section to be an advanced text in spiritual psychology as it examines the individual consciousness, the development of memory, ego, self-awareness, and the relation between the Eternal and the Individual.
Book 2, Part 2, “The Knowledge and the Spiritual Evolution” builds upon the broad overview of Book 1, and the detailed psychological understanding brought to bear in Book 2, Part 1 to now guide us to the conscious role we can play in participating with knowledge in the spiritual evolution. This section leads us systematically to the greater role and purpose that the individual can lay as the lynch-pin of a spiritual evolutionary action that eventually can bring about the transformation of our life in the Ignorance to the development of a life based on Knowledge, what Sri Aurobindo calls The Life Divine. reference: Sri Aurobindo, The Life Divine, Book 2, Part I, Chapter 1, Indeterminates, Cosmic Determinations and the Indeterminable 
Desteni Forums • View topic - 18 The Supermind of Sri Aurobindo ...
 DesteniTV Bernard Poolman  Post subject: 18 The Supermind of Sri Aurobindo and the Secret of LoaPosted:
Sun Mar 14, 2010 5:15 pm
The Secret History of the Law of Attraction Special
Hinduism Part 9
The Supermind of Sri Aurobindo

Written and Narrated by Darryl Thomas

"Hinduism.....gave itself no name, because it set itself no sectarian limits; it claimed no universal adhesion, asserted no sole infallible dogma, set up no single narrow path or gate of salvation; it was less a creed or cult than a continuously enlarging tradition of the God ward endeavour of the human spirit. An immense many-sided and many staged provision for a spiritual self-building and self-finding, it had some right to speak of itself by the only name it knew, the eternal religion, Santana Dharma...." -Sri Aurobindo

As Aurobindo indicates, the strength of Hinduism carries as the oldest religion in the world, is her centuries-old tradition and polymorphic complex of beliefs. Hinduism was able to survive serious attacks from the younger religions of Buddhism, Jainism and Islam by absorbing the strengths of her rivals. The ancient metaphysical system of Hinduism was brought into the modern times by Swami Vivekananda and Sri Aurobindo, who were among the first major post-classical Hindu philosophers who were a major influence within Western spiritual circles.

Sri Aurobindo was born in
Calcutta in 1872, and after being educated in England, became a scholar, writer, yogi, political activist and revolutionary against British Colonialization. His political activities landed him in prison, where he reportedly experienced a spiritual awakening brought on by a vision of the ancient Hindu god, Vasdudeva, causing Aurobindo to turn his focus towards spirituality. Like the Darwin-influenced Theosophists who were currently in vogue at that time, Aurobindo claimed that human beings were "evolving" into higher realms of consciousness - the end result being the perfection of humanity.

According to Aurobindo, the physical evolution of the human being is contingent upon the evolution of man's consciousness, for the physical body was necessary for spiritual development. Thus the "spirit" of human beings uses the physical to experience itself. This message is a bit different from that of say Sankara - where the goal was to acquire a saving knowledge in order to escape the illusion of the material world to unite with Brahman. According to Aurobindo, that unification with the Divine will bring forth a new species of humanity here on the physical plane; a Physical Heaven on Earth. Aurobindo pointed out that religion has failed to direct human beings towards life, focusing instead in separation within the renunciation and denial of the world.

For Aurobindo, "true" religion "seeks after God." By turning one's consciousness "inward," one "produces an identification of self as the "transcendent" self. By this identification and knowledge, Aurobindo says the Divine will finally be able to manifest on earth. Integration and Ascension of the Supermind Aurobindo developed a meditation technique he called "Integral Yoga" which he claimed produced a state of divine bliss-consciousness he called the ‘Supermind’ that would descend into the physical, transforming the person into a divine being. Ignorance will be finally be overcome and liberate the spiritual essence contained within the physical. Aurobindo claimed that there existed a "double process" of integration and ascension that explained creation and the Divine Plan behind existence.

Aurobindo explained it like this: the Divine Mind undergoes a descent into the physical while the physical ascends to the Divine. Thus the physical, which is trapped in ignorance, is redeemed by the knowledge of the Divine Mind, while the divinely-transformed physical now is primed to ascend back to the Divine Consciousness. Much like the religious system of Advaita, it is "knowledge" that transforms and redeems ignorance. Aurobindo presented an unique conception of reality when he claimed that consciousness must emerge from within the physical before the spiritual evolution could arrive to its logical conclusion. While Sankara claimed that evil was the result of ignorance within human consciousness, Aurobindo agreed, and further stated that evil was also necessary for the ego to overcome its limitations. Here Aurobindo brings Sankara's immovable, alien and transcendent Brahman to Earth. Sankara followed the post-Vedic tradition of treating the physical as illusion, but Aurobindo pointed out that if matter exists, it can't be an illusion, because matter is also Brahman. Therefore matter must be real because Brahman is real. Responding to the question of suffering, Aurobindo says since nothing exists but Brahman, it is only Brahman which could actually suffer.

Aurobindo claimed that the Creator's motive for this endless divine integration and physical evolution was the pursuit of Delight. At the same time, this cosmic Delight is the only thing in existence - Aurobindo also promoted the idea that all that existed in creation was, "Joy." While this perspective currently is used by New Age proponents in the belief that suffering isn't "real," this directly contradicts Aurobindo's notion that suffering is experienced by Brahman. The major difficulty of Aurobindo's work is that his metaphysical speculations on the spiritual evolution of mankind and the various layers of transcendent, Divine consciousness has never been verified. The Law of Attraction is reflected within Sri Aurobindo's metaphysical dimensions of the Divine Supermind responding and returning to descend into the human being to be directed again as the energetic force of creation. 
Sources: The Future Evolution of Man - Sri Aurobindo. Conclusion of Preface & Summary by P.B. Saint-Hilaire. August 1962
The Political Philosophy of Sri Aurobindo by V. P. Varma, Motial Barnasidass Publishers, 1960
The Integral Advaitism of Sri Aurobindo by Rāmacandra Miśra,Thirty-Five Oriental Philos by Diané Collinson, Routledge. 1994 The Life Divine by Sri Aurobindo, Lotus Press. 1985

Restoring the text that came out during the yogi-poet’s time.

RECENT ARTICLES
RECENT COMMENTS
RECENT ARTICLES
RECENT COMMENTS

March 19, 2010

Sri Aurobindo and Schopenhauer

The integral advaitism of Sri Aurobindo - Page 19 Rāmacandra Miśra - 1998 - 437 pages
Sri Aurobindo does not take a pessimistic view of life and existence. To the pessimist, the world is full of sorrow and suffering and there is no joy in life. ... AsSchopenhauer puts it, "To me optimism, when it is not merely ... - Book overview 
The Political Philosophy of Sri Aurobindo - Page 128 V. P. Varma - 1990 - 494 pages
... the southern
Mediterranean were also culturally productive and fourthly, in modern times, Indian metaphysics was entering Europe through the writings of Schlegel,Schopenhauer etc. ... Sri Aurobindo, Ideals and Progress, pp. 59-61. ... - Book overview  
Talks with Sri Aurobindo Nirodbaran, Aurobindo Ghose - 1989
Sri Aurobindo: You have the expression of Schopenhauer on your face. (Laughter) M: How, Sir? Sri Aurobindo: The world, according to him, is full of suffering and sorrow, and life an insanity. M: It is just the contrary with me. ... - Book overview  
Mother India: monthly review of culture Sri Aurobindo Ashram - 1986
Sri Aurobindo: You have the expression of Schopenhauer on your face. (Laughter) M: How, Sir? Sri Aurobindo: The world according to him is full of suffering and sorrow, and life an insanity. M: It is just the contrary with me. ... - Book overview  
The philosophy of integralism, or, The metaphysical synthesis ...        Haridas Chaudhuri - 1954 - 366 pages
Schopenhauer fastens upon Will, and erects it into the ultimate principle. The world is, in its essence, so thinksSchopenhauer, a vast omnipotent Will; it is at a much later stage that this Will in the course of its gradual ... - Book overview  
Evening talks with Sri Aurobind Aurobindo Ghose, Ambalal Balkrishna Purani - 1970
Schopenhauer thinks this world a kind of delirium —which almost comes to the theory of illusion. There are others in the West who have taken a similar stand."
20-11-1943 Homage is Sri Aurobindo : By. Dr. KS Aiyangar. ... - Book overview  
The Upanishads - Page 341 Aurobindo Ghose, Sri Aurobindo - 2004 - 597 pages
Neither Shankara nor Schopenhauer have for us the entirety of its knowledge. It is this supreme utility of Vedanta for life, for man's individual and racial evolution that I hope to rescue from the obscuration of quietistic philosophies ... - Book overview 
History of philosophy: eastern and western Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan - 1953
It has become almost a commonplace of philosophical criticism to pit Schopenhauer against Hegel and declare that the real ... for example, done by Sri Aurobindo with the help of his conception of Consciousness-Force, which goes into the... - Book overview  
Correspondence with Sri Aurobindo Nirodbaran, Aurobindo Ghose - 1969 - 356 pages
or Schopenhauer would speak of it, the former say deliberately that dream- sequences and life-sequences stand on the same footing, only they have ... Obscurity and unintelligibility seem to be its very essence! SRI AUROBINDO: ... - Book overview  
Sri Aurobindo circle Aurobindo Ghose - 1998
But I am also expected to speak on it in the Light of Sri Aurobindo - bringing into its scope a third profound idea. Let me focus on the first formidable ... Said Schopenhauer, "Apart from man, no being wonders at its own existence. ... - Book overview