May 08, 2016

Ila Sen, Richard Eggenberger, and Michel Danino

Sunday, May 08, 2016

Talageri has spelled out his theory; MT hasn't

Assorted Tweets:
Musings on AIT, Genetics, and Accusations of Racism: https://t.co/n7IGk6fzVW . My effective refutation of Shrikant Talageri's claims & OIT.

@sighbaboo @KalavaiVenkat has not understood imp point by ST. Population migrations do not prove IE language migration. Only linguistics

This is very sad...like Rajiv Malhotra vs Shatavadhini Ganesh Part 2 😔 https://t.co/2EEysk3cTk

@sowathreya But I would certainly not venture to teach a professional geneticist (MT) about genetics, as many idiots are trying to do.

@ArmchairPseph it's really sad. Talageri really shouldve kept it objective. he goes ad hominem against another blogger too

MT's review of Talageri's work, back when it was released https://t.co/9Yk2IWZNsX

MT on Indians and race: https://t.co/jdLsMfkZ57

Pertinent since Talageri has alleged he is a racist

@ArmchairPseph also this: https://t.co/BeAWBkMKb5 read 1st line. Wonder if "racist" can write this.

MT's insulting and dismissive behaviour towards OIT proponents is wrong, as are Talageri's ad hominem attacks on him.

@TheLordWalrus @ArmchairPseph A healthy debate isn't a bad thing. For the record, MT started the ad-homiem

@ArmchairPseph @TheLordWalrus Even if we forget MT's name calling, the truth is that Talageri has spelled out his theory. MT hasn't.

@Ozymandias1993 u have to trust him, he has extraordinary knowledge and insights across Vedas, linguistics, philology, genetics, history

@Ozymandias1993 its clear that he is in a far better position to evaluate evidence than anyone else i know of. so i shall defer to his jud

@LearntLies No, these are storified tweets of @GhorAngirasa who borrows his support for AIT/AMT from the latest findings of @blog_supplement
Savitri Era of those who adore, Om Sri Aurobindo & The Mother.

No comments:

Post a comment